Peter Penny and his Magic Dollar
SeductionOfTheInnocent.org Homepage     Editions of Seduction of the Innocent, comic books used in Seduction of the Innocent, and the 'Lost SOTI' books     Dr. Fredric Wertham biography, bibliography, and more     The Anti-Comic-Book crusade of the 1940's and 1950's     The Comics Code, which came about in response to the criticisms leveled by SOTI as well as additional public and legislative pressure     Links to sites that have additional related information.     Frequently Asked Questions
      Editions     Found SOTI Comics     Lost SOTI Comics     Wertham Missed It!     SOTI Bibliography     Errors      
 
SeductionOfTheInnocent.org, a site about comic book censorship and more
Banner-free mirror site at www.LostSOTI.org
 

 

The story of Peter Penny and his Magic Dollar

On pages 310-311 of Seduction of the Innocent, Dr. Wertham wrote,
There are publicity comic books to influence adults. Sylvia F. Porter, the financial columnist, writes about a comic book got out by the American Bankers Association: "The aim is not just to amuse you. Not by a long shot. It is to mold your thinking in a specific way." If that is true of good comic books for bankers, isn't it true, too, of bad comic books for children? They mold a child's thinking in a specific way.

This is a reference to one of the Peter Penny comic books published by the American Bankers' Association. Collectors have long presumed this reference to be "Peter Penny and his Magic Dollar." Coming soon! We'll post the article from Sylvia F. Porter, which sheds light on what Dr. Wertham was really referring to.

This is one of the scarcest known SOTI books. As of June, 2020, there is only one reported sale at GPAnalysis.com, for a sale that took place on ComicConnect for a CGC 9.4 copy. Only eight copies of any version have ever been certified by CGC.

There are at least three versions of Peter Penny and his Magic Dollar.

The Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide lists an original and a "redrawn" one. The "redrawn" one is purported to have dimensions of 7 1/4" x 11". However, we at LostSOTI have never seen one with dimensions of 7 1/4" x 11", and it seems these measurements may be incorrect based on about a dozen copies of various printings we have encountered over the years.

There are at least three versions known to exist, and none matches the height of the one listed in Overstreet.

If you have any information about any of these versions, please contact us at SeductionOfTheInnocent.org.

Here are the versions confirmed to exist:
Peter Penny and his Magic Dollar
Version A
Year: 1947
Dimensions: Version A1 has dimensions of 7 3/8" x 10 1/8"
Version A2 reportedly is 1/4" narrower (7 1/8" x 10 1/8").
Binding: Glue

Many thanks to
Marty Mann for
the Version A
information and scan.
Peter Penny and his Magic Dollar
Version B
Year: 1947
Dimensions: 7 1/8" x 10 1/8"
Binding: Glue
Peter Penny and his Magic Dollar
Version C
Year: 1947
Dimensions: 7 1/8" x 10 1/8"
Binding: Glue
Peter Penny and Saves the Day
 
Year: 1948
Dimensions: 6 7/8" x 10"
Binding: Glue


Side by Side Comparison of B and C.
Based on the images below, it seems apparent that version C is a redrawn edition of version B. It's not certain whether version A came before or after versions B and C. However, it appears that version A has a higher level of detail than B or C, leading to conjecture that version A came first.
Version B

Version C (redrawn).

Original version

Redrawn version. Note the empty space where the bottom of the bush was extended.