Seduction of the Innocent: More Anti-Comics Items
SeductionOfTheInnocent.org Homepage     Editions of Seduction of the Innocent, comic books used in Seduction of the Innocent, and the 'Lost SOTI' books     Dr. Fredric Wertham biography, bibliography, and more     The Anti-Comic-Book crusade of the 1940's and 1950's     The Comics Code, which came about in response to the criticisms leveled by SOTI as well as additional public and legislative pressure     Links to sites that have additional related information.     Frequently Asked Questions
  Anti-Comics
 Timeline  
  Anti-Comics
 Articles  
  Love & Death  
  Parade of  
 Pleasure  
  NY Legislative  
  Committee  
  U.S. Senate 
  Investigation  
  More Anti-Comics 
  Items  
   
Marvel/Atlas editorials
In response to Dr. Wertham's attack on comic books
in the Saturday Review of Literature
Below are all of the Marvel comics suspected to have Anti-Wertham editorials,
dated November, 1948 through June, 1949.
Ones that have been confirmed are noted.
Title
  Nov., 1948
  Dec., 1948
  Jan., 1949
  Feb., 1949
  Mar., 1949
  Apr., 1949
  May, 1949
  Jun., 1949
  Jul., 1949
  Notes
All True Crime
  30

 
  31

 
  32

 
  33

 
  34

 
All Western Winners
 
  2 (Winter 1948)

 
  3

 
  4

  Title continues as Western Winners
 
 
 
Amazing Mysteries
 
 
 
 
 
  Title continued from Sub-Mariner comics, per Overstreet. (?)
  32

 
  33

 
Annie Oakley
  4

  Last issue
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Awful Oscar
 
 
 
 
 
 
  Title continues from Oscar
  11
Editorial #4

 
 
Best Western
 
 
 
 
 
 
  Title continued from Terry Toons or Miss America Magazine?
  58

 
 
Blackstone the Magician
  Last issue (4) was Sept, 1948, but title is mentioned on later editorial page.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Blaze Carson
  2

 
  3
Editorial #2

 
  4

 
  Note that the title skipped a month.
  5

 
 
Blonde Phantom
  20

 
  21

 
  22

  Title continues as Lovers
 
 
 
 
Captain America
  69

 
  70

 
  71

 
  72

 
  73

 
Cindy Comics
 
  32
Editorial #1

 
  33
Editorial #2

 
  34
Editorial #3

 
  35

 
  Per eBayer ThePillowQueen, issue 34 contains Editorial #3.
Comedy Comics
  4

 
  5

 
  6

 
  7

 
  8

 
Complete Mystery Stories
 
  3
Editorial #1

 
  4
Editorial #2

  Title continues as True Complete Mystery.
 
 
 
 
 
Crime Fighters
  4

 
  5
Editorial #1

 
  6
Editorial #2

 
  7
Editorial #3

 
  8

 
Frankie and Lana
 
  12

 
  13
Editorial #2

 
  14
Editorial #3

 
  15

 
 
Gay Comics
 
  35

 
  36

 
  37
Editorial #3

 
  38
Editorial #4

 
  Per eBayer ThePillowQueen, #35 contains an editorial, but it's unclear which one. Per eBayer Doyman, issue #37 contains Editorial #3. Per eBayer Bronze!, issue #38 contains Editorial #4.
Georgie Comics
  19

  Title continues as Georgie and Judy
 
 
 
 
 
  Title continued from Georgie and Judy
  23

 
Georgie and Judy
 
  Title continued from Georgie Comics
  20

 
  21
Editorial #2

 
  22
Editorial #3

  Title continues as Georgie Comics
 
 
Hedy DeVine
 
  30

 
  31

 
  32

 
  33

 
 
Human Torch
  33

 
  34

 
  35

  Last issue before 1954
 
 
 
 
Ideal
  3
This book contains no editorial.

 
  4

 
  5

  Last issue
 
 
 
 
Jeanie
  22

 
  23

 
  24
Editorial #2

 
  25

 
  26

  Per eBayer ThePillowQueen, this contains an editorial. Unclear which one.
Joker Comics
  34

 
  35

 
  36

 
  37

 
  38

 
Junior Miss
  31

 
  32

 
  33
Editorial #2

 
  34

 
  35

 
Justice Comics
 
  7

 
  8

  This was very unusal at the time. A monthly Marvel book.
  9

  10
Editorial #3

  11

  12

  Note there were additional issues 7/8/9 in 1947-48.
Kid Colt
 
  3

 
  4
Editorial #2

 
  Note that title skipped a month
  5

 
  6

 
Krazy Komics
  2

  Last issue
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Lana
 
  3

 
  4
Editorial #2

 
  5

 
  6
Editorial #4

 
  Per Tom Raski (eBayer Bronze!), issue #6 contains editorial #4.
Lawbreakers Always Lose
 
  5

 
  6
Editorial #2

 
  7
Editorial #3

 
  8

 
 
Li'l Willie
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
  Title continued from Willie
  20

 
Lovers
 
 
 
 
 
  Title continued from Blonde Phantom
  23

 
  24

 
Margie
 
  44

 
  45

 
  46

 
  47

 
 
Marvel Mystery Comics
 
  89
Editorial #1

 
  90

 
  91

 
  92

 
 
Millie the Model
 
  15

 
  16
Editorial #2

 
  17

 
  18
Editorial #4

 
  Per Dave Reynolds, issue #18 contains Editorial #4.
Mitzi's Boy Friend
 
  5
Editorial #1

 
  6

 
  7
Editorial #3

  Title continues as Mitzi's Romances
 
 
 
Mitzi's Romances
 
 
 
 
 
 
  Title continued from Mitzi's Boy Friend
  8

 
 
My Own Romance
 
 
 
  Title continues from My Romance
  4
Editorial #3

  Note that issues 5 and 6 are dated 1 month apart.
  5
Editorial #2 (?)

  6

 
 
My Romance
  2
Editorial #1

 
  3
Editorial #2

  Title continues as My Own Romance
 
 
 
 
 
 
Namora
 
  3

  Last issue
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Nellie the Nurse
 
  16

 
  17
Editorial #2

 
  18

 
  19

 
 
Oscar
 
  8
Editorial #1

 
  9

 
  10
Editorial #3

  Title continues as Awful Oscar
 
 
  Per eBayer ThePillowQueen, issue #8 contains Editorial #1.
Patsy Walker
  19

 
  20
Editorial #1

 
  21
Editorial #2

 
  22

 
  23

 
Powerhouse Pepper
  5

  Last issue
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Rusty
  19

 
 
 
  Note title had a hiatus of several months.
 
  20

 
  21

 
Sub-Mariner
 
  29

 
  30

 
  31

 
  32

  Overstreet says title continued as Amazing Mysteries #32.
 
Super Rabbit
  14

  Last issue
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Sun-Girl
 
  3

  Last issue
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Teen Comics
  28

 
  29

 
  30

 
  31

 
  32

 
Tessie the Typist
 
  19

 
  20
Editorial #2

 
  21

 
  22

 
 
Tex Morgan
 
  3

 
  4

 
  5

 
  6

 
 
Tex Taylor
  2

 
  3

  4
Editorial #2

 
  5

 
  6

 
True Complete Mystery
 
 
 
 
  Title continues from Complete Mystery.
  5
Editorial #3

 
  6

 
 
Two-Gun Kid
 
  5
Editorial #1

 
  6
Editorial #2

 
  7
Editorial #3

 
  8

 
  Per David T. Alexander, issue #5 contains Editorial #1.
Venus
 
  3

 
  Note the hiatus between issues 3 and 4.
 
  4

 
  5

 
 
Wacky Duck
  Last issue was October, 1948
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Western Winners
 
 
 
 
 
 
  Title continued from All Western Winners
  5

 
 
Wild Western
  4

 
  5

 
  6
Editorial #2

 
  7

 
  8

 
Willie
 
  17

 
  18

 
  19

  Title continues as Li'l Willie